|
Post by SchniTzloR on Apr 17, 2004 16:25:23 GMT -5
I think fotr is best cause not so many canges from book and no stupid legolas-stunt Well Rotk was also gr8 but i hated the ghosts killing all the orcs with just running them down(and mumaks too)... Gondor didnt even need rohan the ghost killed all orcs anyway... Oh yes the pink-faced orc captain was gay!! Why did he controlled the orcs not the wk? And in the fight I didnt see any easters and only a few haradrim sitting on their mumaks.. Ok I stop and I dont write all changes down...
|
|
Alatar_theIstar
Full Member
From clan TBR. Well well... look at that! Uncle Bob came to visit with his cute lill' horse 8)=
Posts: 324
|
Post by Alatar_theIstar on Apr 18, 2004 2:24:15 GMT -5
i missed mouth also ... but i heard from some1 that he will be in the extended edit , well i hope so
|
|
|
Post by narsilLOTR on Apr 18, 2004 5:20:06 GMT -5
well actually the orc "captain" was in book also, of course commander was witch king, but this orc was second in command, and after witch kings death he took control of the battle...
hm and about the ghosts, well they couldnt do it as in the book cos ghosts didnt "fight" on same place then rest there, i.e lossarnach, and a third battle would ve been too long for one movie, so they made ghosts come to pelennor...though I agree, they did too much...well and the rohirrim werent really "useless", they were actually even too strong, in book, yes they killed many orcs, running them down, but they didnt overrun ALL orcs in no time, and men of gondor werent such wimps, after rohirrim coming, they left minas tirith and a long fight started men of rohan/gondor vs orcs/haradrim, untill the king came with corsair ships and reinforcements from lossarnach....
|
|
|
Post by MMG_God on Apr 18, 2004 12:19:23 GMT -5
Oh yea thanks for reminding me narsil cause I hated that. THE ROHIRIAM OWNED! omfg lol. Wasnt it supposed to be a death charge? they instead lost maybe 2 riders at most, orcs that werent even near them were falling down...gay!!!! And they made the men of gondor pussess, they were all wimps, even beregrond seemed to be on the same level of grima wormtongue as far as he was like a sniveling wimp. rawr.
|
|
ToiletDonkey-dk
Full Member
Official Donkey Trainer
HeY im....im...dunno...uhh look ice cream..
Posts: 253
|
Post by ToiletDonkey-dk on Apr 18, 2004 14:56:23 GMT -5
hehe quite angry there ^^ but yea the soldiers of Gondor was wusses... bad move by Peter Jackson
|
|
|
Post by narsilLOTR on Apr 19, 2004 3:33:30 GMT -5
heh well I think what the rohirrim did in movie also happened in book...the first lines of orcs were overrun fast...notice : the FIRST lines, not all 100 000 lol....ofc they can ride down some wild spreaded orcs, but soon the attack came to stop and the fought..err lets say still fought brave, killing many but not all and in no time also the haradrim came with mumkas, yES...cool...loved these big beast...but ffs not ONLY mumkas, they had thousands of footies and of riders also....theodens knights killed easterlings wainraiders....bah oh and the numbers are often so ridiculous too...I mean saruman had about 10 000 uruks, true....but in helms deep, they were not only 300 peasants under arms like movie says...they had 1000 elite riders from edoras, and about 2000 strong soldiers from the westfold, that managed to escape after battle
|
|
Isildur
Full Member
Karma: 0
Posts: 160
|
Post by Isildur on Apr 19, 2004 8:09:47 GMT -5
well I really like the movies but it was so many changes in TTT and RotK that Peter Jacksson could have done much better (I think) but in my opinion the biggest misstake must be that thing with Tom Bombadill cuz it is with help from Tom that Merry, Pippin and Sam get thoose westernesse swords from the barrow witches (they nice looking girls that The Wichmaster from Angbad turned back to life) and it is with one of theese very rare swords made of the elves and then the witches did something to them, that Merry Stabbed The Witchmaster of Angbad with so Èowyn could kill him.....
(I didn´t say Er_Murazor of the easy reason I couldn´t remember the exactly spelling) / Isildur
|
|
|
Post by MMG_God on Apr 19, 2004 15:49:33 GMT -5
Dont worry, Er-murazor is a made up name for him anyway.
|
|
G011um
Junior Member
Posts: 88
|
Post by G011um on Apr 20, 2004 17:11:26 GMT -5
well how could u say the 2 towers suck!!! its the best one GOLLUM!!! he rox then i love the riders of rohan when they ride down 2 charge the uruks at helms with gandi and the ents are really nice 2 only thing i dont like about the 2 towers ist the arwen ara stuff that sux ok u get to see the titts of arwen for like 3 sec but wooooaaah go on a internet side and u have the same ara dont have to fall down into some stupid river for that and everyone thinks he is dead.... well i guess it isnt 2 bad or else the movie would have gained a gay price because of sam and frodos love affaire lol esspecially the last part sucked i was w8ing for shelob and all i got was some stupid stuff about "lets be firends for ever oooooookkkkeeee??? i love u sam i love u master frodo lets have lots of kids bla bla bla " the trixy exhobbit
|
|
IncanusTheMaia
Full Member
"There is only one Lord of the Rings, and he does not share power."
Posts: 132
|
Post by IncanusTheMaia on Apr 26, 2004 11:10:34 GMT -5
'bout that pink orc on RotK, ofc WK was the leader of the army, but HOW THE HELL could he control, what, 100000 orcs AND at the same time fly (with some stupid beast with a bumb mask on his face) destroying those catas (trebuches)? tho, he did that only on the movie, right? well... FotR has 1 bad thing, tho it has some good points 2. gandy "dies" at one point, atleast every1 think so. well, it's true, he dies at one moment, but if u haven't read the book (i have) u don't know what happens 2 him, sniff... well it's a VERY VERY important scene, so it would had been REALLY REALLY dumb to let it out... btw, gandy is the greatest guy in LOTR ^^ but, in the films, gandy the whites hair is too straight, he looks more familiar as grey oh well, gr8 movies those are, and TTT is good 2, tho it has most mistakes... why the hell so few warriors survive at helm's deep?? they are like 5-10 at the end of the battle + some dudes in the castle, who hide from orcs (prolly) About RotK, yes, where are the )=(%#=)¤("= wainriders?!?!? theoden freakin slays the flag, the black serpent (or something) and gets the moral of the haradrim/easters dooooooooown... and yes, WHERE IS THE BATTLE OF THE SHIRE??? murr... oh well, i guess u can't have all ^^ great movies, i gotta buy em all as extended vers
|
|
AxE
Junior Member
The one who you should NOT fuck with.... cuz he might like it and try to hump when ur not looking
Posts: 99
|
Post by AxE on Apr 27, 2004 7:48:55 GMT -5
incase ur wondering the "pink" orc's name is Gothmog and he was the second in charge after murazor in the battle for tirith RotK sucked in my opinion... no Imrahil, no Beregond, no Fat man(didn't remember his name) and no archers, since it was those who killed the mumakils and no the rohirrim... also it didn't include Aragorns healing and it was totally wrong at the battle of the black gate, since they weren't surrounded in that way, there were orc reinforcements behind them in hiding that leapt forvard and took them in the back and there is no battle when the hobbits return(WTF!??!)
|
|
Aeonking
Junior Member
Sorcerer of Khand
k thx
Posts: 76
|
Post by Aeonking on Apr 27, 2004 17:37:13 GMT -5
Rotk Sucked missed out too much was boring and i just didnt like it . FotR was by far the best.
is it more or does gandy turn into a complete asshole when he becomes gandy the white?
|
|
|
Post by Kieron on Apr 29, 2004 17:20:03 GMT -5
What i still dont understand is at the battle of the black gates....what the hell happened to the horses?....gondors and rohans men ride up....get surronded...and poof....where in gods name have those horses boggered off to.....and why did it look like there were only 50 men come to challange the black gate not that i'm being picky...
|
|
lMrahiL
New Member
I'm Blesses by Ulmo
Posts: 19
|
Post by lMrahiL on May 1, 2004 6:07:13 GMT -5
ROTK for sure, the best part is the riding of rohan thats so cool :)oh and when gandalf go solo to rescue faramir, hehe.
|
|
|
Post by narsilLOTR on May 1, 2004 10:30:35 GMT -5
well about drisc´s question....also in book they didnt use horses, they stood on 2 small hills, and awaited orcs to charge, then hold as long as possible untill eagles came (giving their some time) and finally the ring to be destroyed, then they slay the easterlings and haradrim, orcs ran away....
|
|